Did
he really say that? I wasn't going to comment
on this until I hear what ICANN CEO and President
Paul Twomey has to say about it, but since many
other sites are already buzzing (and possibly jumping to
conclusions) about it, I'll offer my initial thoughts on
the developing |
brouhaha.
It started when an article
at GulfNews.com
(a site that covers developments in the Middle East)
had Twomey lumping domainers into the same
category as cybersquatters and typosquatters
when he spoke at an Internet conference in Dubai
last week. When commenting about the possible
introduction of new TLDs and IDNs that would allow local
languages to be used on both sides of the dot,
reporter Scott
Shuey quoted Twomey as saying that while
many would welcome the ability to have
domain names in their native languages, there are a
number of downsides, including cyber-squatting,
typo-squatting and domaining.
Shuey
added (and the absence of quotation marks in his article
leads me to believe these are his words, not Twomey's)
"Domaining, which is technically legal, is still
somewhat controversial. Domainers purchase
non-trademarked domain |
Dr.
Paul Twomey
ICANN President and CEO |
names
in the hopes of either reselling the name at a profit.
Some websites have resold for millions of dollars. Other
domainers "park" the domain in order to
generate advertising revenue. A parked site usually
reroutes users to a website that contains ads. While a
number of international laws and internal procedures
discourage squatting, domaining is going to be an
issue, Twomey said."
My
initial reaction when I read this article is that Dr.
Twomey would not say something so appallingly
ignorant and I think that will turn out to be true.
Twomey is familiar with the domain business and I had a front row
seat when he delivered a solid
keynote address at the 2006
Domain Roundtable conference in Seattle.
I
am cautious about taking the comments attributed
to him at face value because it is a sad fact
that people are frequently misquoted in news
reports. It has happened many times to me when I
have been interviewed by others, including top
notch news organizations. In fact the most
blatant instance of this occurred when a Washington
Post reporter (who has since left the
paper) twisted things I said beyond recognition.
The Post just won six Pulitzer prizes
this |
|
week
so if it can happen there it can happen
anywhere.
The
Internet
Commerce Association is sending
Twomey a letter asking him to confirm what
was said in Dubai. If it turns out he really did
say this then my opinion would be that he should
resign from ICANN. However,
until I hear it from the horse's mouth I will
have a real problem believing the comments
attributed to Twomey are accurate.
(Posted
April 8,
2008) |
|