Welcome to
DN Journal's 18th annual State of the Industry
Cover Story! We have again called on leading experts from
across the domain industry to get their take on the
forces that fueled a boom year for domains in 2021
and their forecasts for 2022.
While
the year began with no sign of a slowdown in the
domain business, there could be some road hazards
ahead. There is increasing competition
from other digital assets like NFTs and cryptocurrency,
borrowing money will cost more with interest rates
rising to combat inflation and, after two years, the
biggest wild
|
Image
from Bigstock
|
card
of all - the ongoing global pandemic - is still in
play. There is a lot to keep up with and no better
time to find out how people with some of the best
track records in the business view what is
ahead.
To
assemble our panel we called on successful domain
investors, developers and brokers, as well corporate
leaders from a variety of categories including
registrar and registry operators, aftermarket sales
platforms and conglomerates that offer all of those
services and more. Many of our experts operate in more
than one category. For those multi-tasking
individuals, we put them in the group that looks most
relevant them this year. To assure fresh voices are
always in the mix, we aim to have about half of each
year's panel comprised of members who were not
featured the previous year, and were able to do that
again this year.
Since we value the
opinions of every expert equally,
we rotate the order that each group appears in each year. Last year we led with the
Domain Brokers, followed by
Corporate Leaders, then Domain Investors &
Developers. So this year, the Corporate
Leaders and Domain
Investors & Developers each rotate up
a notch with the Domain
Brokers moving into the anchor position.
While you can read the article straight through, the links
in the preceding sentence also give you the option of
going directly
to any group. You
can also instantly go to any individual
commentator just by clicking their photo in
the collage below
(with the exception of my photo at the end - my role
was just to ask the questions, gather the answers and
share them with you). Once you go to an expert you can
also copy the URL from your browser bar if you want to
share that person's comments with others. Now,
it is my pleasure to introduce the
experts who have graciously taken time out of their
busy schedules to share their insights with you. I'm
confident you will find it very valuable in your own
journey thourgh an industry where there is no such
thing as too much information!
|
Our
2022 Panel of Experts |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
(Left
to right):
Row
1: Michael Robrock
(Sedo), David Warmuz (Trellian/Above.com), Matt
Overman (Donuts), Sandeep
Ramchandani (Radix).
Row 2:
Daniel
Negari (.XYZ), Zak Muscovitch (Internet Commerce Association
& The Muscovitch Law Firm), David
Castello (Castello
Cities Internet Network), Michael
Castello (Castello Cities Internet Network).
Row
3: Larry Fischer
(GetYourDomain.com & NFT.net), Nat Cohen (Telepathy),
Braden Pollock (LegalBrandMarketing.com),
Andrew Allemann (DomainNameWire.com).
Row
4: Chris Zuiker (MediaOptions.com),
Kate
Buckley (Buckley
Media), Joe Uddeme (NameExperts.com),
Andrew Miller (ATM Holdings, Inc.). Row
5: Ryan McKegney (DomainAgents.com), Jeff
Gabriel (SAW.com), Amanda Waltz
(SAW.com), George Hong (Guta.com). Row
6:
Tessa Holcomb (DomainAdvisors.com), Mark
Ghoriafi (MrPremium.com),
Ron Jackson (Editor
and Publisher of DNJournal.com's State of the
Industry report - no link with this photo).
|
Domain Investors
...Now,
let's get this party started!
Corporate
Leaders
Michael
Robrock
CEO, Sedo.com
After
a successful 20-year career in online marketing, Michael
Robrock took on a major role at Sedo in
August 2019 as their new Chief Operating Officer.
Barely a year later, on Sept.
1, 2020, Robrock was picked to lead
the company as the industry giant's new CEO
and his first full year on the job showed how well
the company chose.
Michael
Robrock
CEO,
Sedo.com |
Sedo
had a very successful year in 2020,
despite the onset of the Covid-19
pandemic. As anticipated, Sedo
gained further positive momentum
in 2021. I can say with
confidence that 2021 was an
outstanding domain year for Sedo, as
both the volume of domain sales and
the total revenue increased
significantly. This twofold
achievement is based on several
reasons:
The
classic "face to face"
business model failed to bounce back
last year, against all expectations.
Those who did not yet offer business
services online seized the
opportunity to make a move and
acquire the necessary domain names.
This increased demand was noticeable
in the primary domain market, as
well as in the secondary market.
In
addition, many offline businesses
initially invested in online
advertising, such as social media
platforms and search engine
optimization, but had to move
onto domain names. To be
independent and sustainable in the
long term, businesses saw the
necessity to operate their own
domain. That apparent epiphany
emerged quickly, thus increasing the
demand for domains among this target
group as well.
|
In
line with the ongoing trend toward
digitization, the domain parking
business was also
extraordinarily successful in 2021.
Online advertising on parked domains
is highly targeted and has achieved
exceptional growth since the
beginning of the pandemic. I
anticipate that this trend will
continue in 2022.
While
the continued success of ccTLDs
in 2021 was to be expected and thus
not a big surprise, the rebranding
of Facebook to Meta
can be considered a highlight.
Domain
rebranding involves the strategy
of securing the most important
domains before the rebranding
is publicized. In addition, the
process involves the negotiation and
acquisition of other,
"satellite" domains—this
process usually takes place via the
secondary market. The
process is a clear, high level
confirmation that buying domains
is as easy, fast and solid as any
other online purchase.
Furthermore, this type of engagement
encourages other brand operators in
search of a rebranding to follow the
same process, securing all important
domains on both the primary and
secondary markets.
Another
highlight was the rebranding of the
financial services company
"Square" to
"Block" at block.xyz,
following the example of Google's
parent company Alphabet at abc.xyz.
Image
from Bigstock
Many
of the popular trends that drove the
domain market in 2021 will continue
this year:
-
Domains
related to Crypto &
Blockchain, NFTs, VR, Artificial
Intelligence—boosted by the
impact of Metaverse.
-
Medtech
and Fintech—especially medical
cannabis due to countries
loosening cannabis restrictions.
-
Domains
related to climate change,
environmental protection,
sustainability and renewable
energy, and Gaming.
I
project that there will be an
increase in new gTLD sales, and
that ccTLD sales will continue to
perform very strongly. With .io
and .ai already rising in
sales presence in the last two
years, we can expect new ccTLDs
gaining popularity via a niche
market, such as .gg, and a
good ride for new gTLDs such as
.xyz.
Industry
consolidation will continue to
play a role in 2022, either in the
form of mergers of large companies,
or acquisitions of startups. Premium
domains will increase in price, as
demand continues to rise unabated.
Many
mature startups would decide to
invest increased capital on domains,
primarily to establish presence on
the optimal TLD, .com. Additionally,
big brands and corporations will
continue to optimize their domain
strategy, striving for a shorter,
easy to remember domain. The
result will be a very noticeable
increase in the sales numbers
related to ultra premium domains.
Sedo
cruised at high altitude in 2021 but
that is nothing new for CEO Michael
Robrock (2nd from right in seats
on the right side of this cargo plane flying
over Prague). Robrock took
the flight with some fellow
attendees at the 2010 Domainfest
Conference in the Czech capital. (Photo
taken by
Trellian
Founder David Warmuz).
Investors
eager to trade current digital
investment topics such as cryptocurrencies
or NFTs, will sooner or later
get involved with domain names
as tradeable digital assets.
As
a result, more investors would
establish an active presence in the
domain industry as lateral entrants,
fueling domain prices due to higher
demand. Let's not forget that
inflation also boosts domain prices,
because domains are considered a safe
investment haven with low risk,
comparable to real estate and art.
The
subject of cybersecurity will
continue to grow in importance in
2022, as online businesses of every
size deal with this topic, inevitably
as part of their digital strategy;
domains are an important part of this.
As
a whole, the domain industry tends to
react and correlate with current
events and trends. New social media
platforms such as Clubhouse
emerge, influencer popularity on Instagram
or YouTube increases, and
blockchain technology products such as
cryptocurrencies and NFTs
arrive, all while the Covid-19
pandemic diminishes direct face to
face business. But in the end, people
go online to seek something out and
end up with a domain!
Domain
names provide independence, security,
improved customer retention, traffic
growth, and reduction of advertising
costs. This will not change in
2022. What became noticeable for so
many companies in 2020 will be more
present and clear for everyone in
2022: Your domain is your home.
With
this in mind, at Sedo we look forward
to a great domain year full of new
ideas, insights, and hopefully more
personal encounters at various domain
industry events! |
|
|
|
David
Warmuz
Founder & CEO, Trellian.com
and Above.com
Trellian.com
Founder David Warmuz celebrated the company's 24nd
anniversary in 2021. David, who serves as CEO of both Trellian
its popular domain monetization, aftermarket and brokerage
platform, Above.com, launched Trellian with his late
brother Ren and their remarkable journey was detailed in a
November 2017 DNJournal Cover
Story.
David
Warmuz
Founder & CEO
Trellian.com & Above.com |
2020
was a catalyst for many changes that were further refined
in 2021. As expected many workflow improvements
implemented made 2021 our Strongest yet!
All of our divisions saw good increases in revenues,
market share and more staff. Though hiring staff has
become harder and the process taking longer without
physical interviews, while working from home in constant
lock-downs, we see the the need to be mindful of mental
health issues that this extended isolation is creating.
On a sad note, we mourn the loss of a key member of our
team who unexpectedly passed away from heart disease at
the low age of 40. Rest in peace Matthew Clarke as you
are missed by all.
My 2020 Bitcoin Prediction "2021 will see a number of
bitcoin price corrections and multiple runs that I expect
to surpass the current top price." was spot on.
New top price of $69,000 was set and currently on a
correction that is still above where I expected it to be.
For 2022 I cannot confidently say that we will surpass the
current top price but we sure will get close. Though I
will be happy to get this prediction wrong! |
Our
professional Above Managed service to help manage
domain portfolios was our focus in 2021 and generated exceptional
returns for many new clients that transitioned.
Greater demand for domain traffic saw constant increases
in performance. Unfortunately the travel industry took
longer to recover and is still not where it used to be, so
we look forward to this vertical to resume its recovery in
2022.
Monetization and domain sales will continue to trend
upward in 2022 and we have ready buyers of traffic
domain portfolios on revenue multiple with substantial
budgets, so if looking to sell please reach out.
A wish for 2022 is that there will be a few face to face
events where we can once again catch up...
And yes we are still hiring! |
Matt
Overman
Senior VP, Sales - Donuts
Inc.
Matt
Overman has been a leading domain industry executive for over
15 years now. He started an Demand Media, then
became General Manager of NameJet before moving up to
Senior VP positions at Rghtside and now Donuts
(owner ond administrator of the world's largest portfolios of new
gTLDS).
Matt
Overman
Senior VP, Sales - Donuts Inc. |
2021
was another crazy year for domains and digital identity
assets. I'm sure other contributors more closely connected
with the NFT boom will share their 2021 reflections in
that area; but what I will say is that the growth of all
things web3 - the metaverse, DeFi, NFTs and other
blockchain based tech - was a major driver of domain
registration growth this year.
Within
the Donuts portfolio, ‘coin’, ‘tech’, ‘cryp’,
‘meta’ and ‘verse’ were all amongst the top 20
most commonly registered keywords. I expect that web3 and
other emerging tech will continue as major themes in 2022,
materializing in greater demand for TLDs already popular
amongst tech / blockchain companies such as .ai, .co, .io,
.finance and .xyz.
There
continues to be disportionately high usage of nTLDs and
ccTLDs amongst major crypto companies. Looking at the top
100 cryptocurrencies by market cap, 44 companies or
projects use an nTLD or ccTLD for their primary website,
including 11 that use a .network. |
Another
trend we saw at Donuts was stronger than anticipated
renewal rates in 2021. This follows an increase in
demand driven by Covid lockdowns in 2020, as well as a
focus on improved quality of domain registration. This is
one of a number of indicators that the pandemic-driven
movement of businesses online will be lasting.
I
expect the red hot aftermarket to continue in 2022.
I also believe more and more startups and entrepreneurs
will embrace ccTLDs and nTLDs due to the lack of
availability and affordability of desirable .COM names. Morgan
Linton wrote this year about the increase in funded
companies using nTLDs for their websites. DomainsBot
also published a study showing that consumers only find a
two-word .COM 13% of the time and at the same time are
actually conducting less domain searches! I believe both
of these are indicative of the challenge in finding a good
.COM and more openness to building businesses on
descriptive domains.
Finally,
online security will continue to grow in importance
for domains and digital assets in general in 2022. I
expect the investment in online security to increase
dramatically this year to combat all types (theft, fraud
etc.) and address all layers (application, network etc.). This
will remain a priority area for Donuts, continuing
security-based innovation within our products, services
and systems to ensure better protection for our partners
and for consumers. |
Sandeep
Ramchandani
CEO, Radix
(part of the Directi Group)
In
2018 Sandeep Ramchandani completed a 15-year rise through
the ranks to become CEO
at Radix Registry, a position he continues
to thrive in at a company that operates nine new gTLDs and one
re-purposed ccTLD as part of industry giant Directi Group.
Radix now has millions of domains under management.
Sandeep
Ramchandani
CEO, Radix |
After
the unprecedented Covid driven spike that we experienced
in 2020, 2021 was all about testing the
sustainability of that growth.
Looking
at things more closely from a Radix perspective, in
2020 we saw a sharp rise in new sales across most of our
TLDs; in both the premium and standard categories. When it
came to forecasting 2021, we had two big challenges:
i)
Predicting new unit sales. Historically, we have been
able to safely predict a reasonable growth rate over the
previous year, but that wouldn’t have worked since 2020
was an outlier. It was near impossible to make a
scientific forecast for how 2021 would play out given the
oscillating macro economic environment which was tossing
between the world getting back to normalcy vs new Covid
waves forcing further lock-downs.
ii)
Predicting renewals of spike sales in 2020. Past data
clearly shows the correlation between sudden new unit
spikes and lower renewals. That approach was also
supported by the hypothesis that a large contributor of
the growth was driven by distressed businesses trying to
get online to stay alive, and that such businesses are
likely to |
experience
higher churn. So, we did the reasonable thing and assumed
that domains registered in 2020 would renew at slightly
lower rates when compared to previous years.
As
we look back at the past year, it's interesting to see how
things turned out across these two critical metrics:
i)
New Unit Sales. Our standard (non premium) sales were
largely flat over 2020. While we’d love to have it grown
over 2020, this wasn't a bad result given that in 2020 new
sales were 50% higher than in 2019. To have sustained that
level of new sales was considered a good result for us.
Premium names saw a spectacular jump of 32% over 2020.
Given that 2020 itself had seen a 52% rise over the
previous year, this beat our most optimistic expectations.
ii)
Renewal Trends of names registered in 2020. We were
pleasantly surprised as we witnessed one of our best ever
years for first time renewal rates. Standard names
registered in 2020 renewed at 44% higher and renewal rates
for premium names for the same period saw a 4% rise over
the previous year.
Looking
at 2022 and beyond, we see e-commerce as
being the largest growth driver for our industry.
Image
from Bigstock
As
per an internal analysis, the total number of e-commerce
websites globally jumped from 5 million by the
start of 2020 to over 12 million by the end of the
year. This segment has substantially outpaced the overall
market. The percentage of websites which are now
e-commerce enabled jumped from 5% at the start of 2020 to
11% by the end of the year and has risen further to 15.5%
by the end of 2021.
Shopify,
which is a good barometer for this segment, has seen its
share price rise 300% in the two years between Jan
2020 and Dec 2021. Based on data from IBM’s
US Retail Index, the pandemic has accelerated
the shift away from physical stores to digital shopping by
roughly five years.
These
numbers present a huge opportunity for the entire
web services industry. Since each e-commerce website
represents a direct channel of revenue, its economic value
and resultant investment in infrastructure, marketing and
maintenance is substantially higher than a basic website.
Case in point, Wix’s
share of revenue from e-commerce websites has
gone from 13% in 2016 to 37% in 2020, and
Wix isn’t even positioned as an e-commerce specialist.
If
the percentage of e-commerce sites stabilize at around
15-20%, this next wave of new sites will, in absolute
dollar terms, represent a massive opportunity for
registries, registrars, hosters, domainers and e-commerce
service providers.
As
the operator of the .Store TLD, we’re placing
special emphasis in trying to position it as the de facto
TLD for anyone who is looking to set up a website with a
sales objective. There's a good reason for all companies
in our industry to have a specific strategy to ride this
wave. |
Daniel
Negari
Founder & CEO, .XYZ
Back
in 2011, Daniel Negari got the idea that since the alphabet
ends with XYZ, why not end domain names the same way? When ICANN
opened up new gTLD applications in 2012 he applied for .xyz,
got it and went live with the extension in 2014, positioning the
TLD as a short,
memorable, affordable, global, and flexible choice for anyone's
online presence. Over the past two years, .xyz has been on fire,
especially in Web3 communities.
Daniel
Negari
Founder & CEO, .XYZ |
In
2021 the most significant trend, by far, was the
widespread adoption and use of new gTLD domains. It
is now commonplace to see new gTLD domains at the top of
the weekly sales charts, demonstrating healthy aftermarket
volume and increasing demand. New gTLD registrations are
also up across our registrar partners as new internet
users are presented with more available and affordable
domain choices. I’m especially proud of the
extraordinary growth of .xyz. In 2021 .xyz became
the 13th most popular TLD in the world (source: https://domainnamestats.com
). In addition, .xyz is the 5th most popular Generic TLD
(com/net/org/info/xyz) and the #1 new gTLD in the world.
One
unexpected trend in 2021 was the huge growth of NFTs
and new technologies like Web3 gaining traction. We
saw a number of crypto and web3 companies like Block.xyz,
Matcha.xyz, and Dune.xyz
rebrand to a next generation .xyz domain. We have been
working closely with blockchain organizations (ex: Ethereum
Name Service) for over 5 years so while it doesn't
come as a surprise to see .xyz become the go-to domain
ending, it was a surprise to see such large rebrands all
at once! |
I
anticipate that 2022 will be an even bigger year
for the domain industry. As a result of registrars
offering more domain options and algorithmically showing
the best suited option(s) in the search results, internet
users will have an easier time finding a memorable and
relevant domain to register. I predict that registrars
will get even smarter and improve user experience,
allowing domain registrants to easily set up websites and
other relevant products more quickly. I also forecast a
continued upward trend of new gTLD registrations,
especially in the crypto and NFT space. Many
more blockchain-powered companies and developers will be
coming online and will want to use affordable and
memorable domain extensions like .xyz. I am incredibly
excited to see what new innovations and trends 2022 will
bring and the team at XYZ looks forward to facilitating
the growth and expansion of the internet. |
Zak
Muscovitch
General Counsel
at Internet
Commerce Association & Principal at The Muscovitch
Law Firm
Veteran
Toronto-based attorney Zak Muscovitch has long been
acknowledged for his expertise in UDRP issues but he has
also gained acclaim for the extraordinary work he has done as
General Counsel for the Internet Commerce Association (the
non-profit organization that protects to domain registrant
rights). 2021 was a landmark year for both the ICA and Zak's
private practice.
Zak
Muscovitch
ICA General Counsel
Principal, Muscovitch Law Firm |
From
my perspective, 2021 was the year that Domain
Name Investing finally reached its destiny of being a
widely acknowledged and legitimate industry and reached
new, unprecedented heights.
I
witnessed this in both of my roles; as General Counsel to
the Internet
Commerce Association and as a private practice
domain name lawyer. As General Counsel of the ICA, 2021
saw more UDRP
panelist and more UDRP panelist decisions recognizing and
respecting domain name investing as a legitimate
industry worthy of protection against illegitimate
attempts to scoop valuable domain names for free via the
UDRP. This has been the culmination of years of
extremely hard and talented work by domain name attorneys
in our industry combined with unprecedented outreach by
the ICA to stakeholders within the broader domain name
field.
One
of the highlights for us was co-hosting along with the International
Trademark Association, the first-ever “mock”
UDRP hearing at Namescon. Not only did
this attract some of the very best panelists and counsel
to participate, but it demonstrated the complexities of
the UDRP to a |
broader
audience and showcased cooperation between domain name
investors and trademark representatives. When it comes
to cybersquatting, we can often be on the same page as
cybersquatting not only harms trademark interests, but
also domain name investing.
Also,
through weekly dialogues on the UDRP hosted by
renown UDRP Panelist and author, Gerald Levine, we
increased understanding and appreciation for the strengths
and weaknesses of the UDRP by domain name investors and
trademark representatives alike. Just a few short years
ago, such dialogue, cooperation, and mutual understanding
would have been nearly unthinkable. Furthermore, in
2021 we saw an unprecedented recognition of the domain
name investment bar as a result of the CIIDRC’s
appointment of me to be a UDRP Panelist.
Although I represent both complainants and respondents in
UDRPs, this is the first time that a UDRP lawyer
who is associated with domain name investing as opposed to
exclusively with trademark interests, has been accredited
to hear UDRP cases.
In
my private practice, I saw unprecedented transactional
activity. Extraordinarily high-value domain name
transactions became the norm in 2021, which demonstrated
to me that well funded companies are now, more than ever
before, recognized the incredible value in generic and
brandable domain names. Whereas prior to 2021, I would see
transactions in the six and sometimes low 7 figures, in
2021 I saw transactions in the high 7 figures and even
8 figures. This shows how after 20+ years of domain
name investing waiting for the market to mature, it has
finally happened and will continue to happen as more and
more companies realize that the value that they an get
from the right domain name is a bargain. Moreover, with
such high value transactions comes much more complex deals
thereby demonstrating that the industry’s transactional
acumen and capabilities has to increase accordingly along
with the size and sophistication of the deals.
Zak
Muscovitch speaking at the 2020 NamesCon Global conference
in Austin, Texas.
With
the maturation of the domain name investment business
into a robust, recognized, and extraordinarily
successful industry, comes the need for domain name
investors to step up their game in every respect. This
requires domain name investors to become more active in
several respects in 2021. First, domain name investors
must increase their support and protection of their
industry to safeguard the tremendous gains they made
in 2021. The Internet Commerce Association has been on the
vanguard of this effort for over 15 years and I
call upon every domain name investor who has benefited
from the industry to join
the ICA or to increase its contributions to
that the ICA can expand its efforts on behalf of the
community.
Second,
domain name investors need to increase their awareness
and opposition to cybersquatting so that there is
always a clear difference between the lawful and
legitimate business of trading in domain names on the
secondary market and cybersquatting. Third, domain name
investors need to start thinking bigger about the
value of their domain names in a maturing and
unprecedented seller’s market and work towards
increasing broad public recognition of the
important role that domain name investors play in the
domain name ecosystem. Domain name investors cannot afford
to toil in obscurity any longer and must work together to
maintain the gains that they have made and to further the
goal of bringing distinction and success to the domain
name investment industry. What a year 2021 was and 2022
should be even more tremendous! |
Next
up....
Domain
Investors & Developers
David
Castello
COO,
Castello Cities Internet Network (CCIN)
Co-Founder, CastelloBrothers.com
David
Castello co-founded Castello Brothers LLC with his
brother Michael in 1997 and well as Castello Cities
Internet Network in 1999. As owners and developers of some of
the best .com domains on the web over past 25 years they are true
industry pioneers.
David
Castello
CCIN COO |
In
2020 I wrote an article
for CircleID where I predicted the pandemic would
launch a domain name gold rush, particularly for
generic dotCom, and that’s exactly what happened. DNJournal’s
Top 100 Sales
Chart for 2021 boasts fourteen
seven-figure dotCom sales, not counting those with NDAs,
and 89 out of the Top 100 were dotCom.
My logic was simple. The pandemic was shutting down
brick-and-mortars and forcing them to survive online.
Having a brick-and-mortar with an online presence is one
thing, but surviving strictly online is a completely
different animal, and they quickly learned the #1 rule of
the internet marketing jungle:
The name matters.
The name matters not so much for the first time they find
you, but for the second and third and fourth time when
your name is so instantly memorable that the public
doesn’t have to search for it - and nothing does that as
effectively as a single-word generic dotCom domain name. |
Those of us in this industry tend to forget that
the domain name Aftermarket is less than thirty years
old. Compared to other industries we’re still in our
infancy.
The pandemic proved that the right domain, the right brand, can mean success or failure to an online business. We discovered this ourselves when my brother
Michael and I developed PalmSprings.com in 1995 and
Nashville.com in 2003.
And it still holds true today. Nashville.com does millions of dollars in concert ticket sales a year. No one has to do a search for Nashville.com once they’ve been there because it’s an instantly memorable name. The same rule applies to online giants such as Amazon.com, Cars.com and Hotels.com.
Before 2021, most traditional brick-and-mortars believed the idea that a domain name could solely make or break a business was an urban myth created during the 1999 dotCom bubble. Now, because of the pandemic,
they know better.
I want to stress that we’re talking Endusers here, not domain investors. We’ve sold few of our undeveloped names to investors and they will play a diminishing role in 2022.
2022 will be the Age of the Enduser. |
Michael
Castello
CEO, Castello Cities Internet Network (CCIN)
Co-Founder, CastelloBrothers.com
In
addition to being a pioneering and highly successful and visionary
domain investor (with sales including Whisky.com at $3.1
million), Michael Castello and his brother David
have developed
multiple successful websites (Michael and David were profiled in our December 2006 Cover
Story). As a proven industry visionary we often
turn to Michael for in-depth analysis of where this business is
headed. The pandemic curtailed the time we had to connect for this
year's State of the Industry story, but it didn't stop it, once
again proving there is no keeping a good man down!
Michael
Castello
CEO, Castello Cities Internet Network
Co-Founder, CastelloBrothers.com |
Just
so happens that my family and I caught COVID in the
lead up to this article, so I have not had much time to
write what I wanted. While my comments may be much
shorter, I am happy my brother David is back to
contributing this year.
I believe most of what I wrote in last year’s 2021 State
of the Industry was on target. I hope you’ll read
it again sometime.
What was of most importance to me in 2021 was Facebook
moving its efforts into virtual reality with a Metaverse
platform name change utilizing their Oculus headset.
I expect a headset interface race with big
money coming into the space soon.
Domain names are the truest tangible of virtual value with
other three decades of use. All the trillion-dollar
companies are relying on them.
Looking more at the future, I do not see any real controls
or legislation to curb
these powerful companies that have carved out
the entrepreneurial middle class. The real controls will
be weighted on the rest of us.
See the vision: Register and build conceptualized domain
names. I don’t see a problem with taking risks in NFTs
and crypto for the next several years, but be aware
that in risking too much
|
could
bring down the whole house of cards. Trust and the
perception of security are very important. We shouldn’t
be too keen on sacrificing the bedrock which got us to
this creative moment. We are near the 100-year mark from
the great depression. As with the pandemic of 1920, we
should take note that things do seem to repeat themselves.
Stay well. |
|
Larry
Fischer
Founder, GetYourDomain.com
& NFT.net
Speaking
of industry pioneers, Larry Fischer is another one
who is always part of that conversation. Only a handful of
people on the globe have enjoyed the kind of success as a
domain investor, broker and now (with NFT.net)
developer, that Larry has. Even though most of his high end
sales are in that stratospheric level that is typically
subject to NDAs, he has been able to release enough of them
to be a constant presence on our annual top sales chart. In
2021 his credits included Marketing.com at $2.5
million and Near.com at $1.15 million.
Larry
Fischer
Founder
GetYourDomain.com and NFT.net |
As
the world entered the 2nd year of the Pandemic, online
usage has dramatically increased. With that, the
demand for short 1-word domains has skyrocketed.
In the past year, strategic category leading 1-word
domain names such as Marketing.com, Need.com,
Home.com, Meta.com, NFT.com
and NFT.net have sold, some well into the
8 figures. The two groups of domains names that
rose to levels unexpected, were domains in the Meta
and NFT categories. The metaverse along with NFT’s
are become the fastest growing areas in the
evolution of the Internet. Be prepared as these
two categories show no sign of slowing down.
I
predict that 2022 will be one of the best
years ever in aftermarket sales for domain
names. In the short term, I see no stopping the
increased need and rising prices for generic
category domains in the .com, .net and
.org space. I expect a lot of domain investors
to expand beyond domains into the NFT
explosion. During the last year, NFT’s have
infiltrated the domain investor space. Several key
domainers have become large investors of NFT’s.
Some have created their own NFT projects. In
addition, there will be further speculation in to
blockchain domains. While the chance of success
in the long term has its limits for these assets,
there seems to be money to burn so anything goes. |
Nat
Cohen
Founder, Telepathy
When
people talk about who might hold the world's most valuable
domain portfolio, Nat Cohen's name almost certainly
comes up. You may not hear his name as often as some, only
because the humble investor keeps a low profile and, due to
NDAs, doesn't release details of most of his sales, but the
names speak for themselves. Nat has also been at the
forefront on the fight to protect domain owner's rights
through his service to and constant support of the Internet
Commerce Association.
Nat
Cohen
Founder, Telepathy |
2021
was a strong year for Telepathy thanks to solid
demand and to domain names moving closer to being
properly valued in the marketplace. It
has been a long process for businesses to fully
appreciate the lifetime value of the benefits
they'll receive from a powerful domain name. In
2021, the general attitude of businesses towards
quality domain names took a big step from
"nice to have" to "need to
have", with valuations rising accordingly.
I
was surprised at the demand last year for repurposed
ccTLDs like .io, .co, .gg, .ai,
etc. Those investors who got in early did
extremely well. Does acquiring domain names in
these extensions still represent a good opportunity
for investors, or will the action jump to new,
currently undiscovered extensions?
The
explosive growth in the number of companies focused
on cryptocurrencies and NFTs brought new
money and demand for domain names - while also
seducing many prominent domain investors to shift
their focus away from domain names :)
Another
positive trend from 2021 was the acceleration of
innovative offerings by aftermarket sales platforms, including
Dan.com, SquadHelp, |
Efty,
GoDaddy and others. They are addressing
a long-standing need in the industry to make it
easier for buyers to discover relevant domain names
and to reduce the friction in completing an
aftermarket purchase.
2022
offers many exciting opportunities. If we can
shake off COVID and return to a sense of normalcy,
we should be in a strong economic environment where
we can consolidate the increases in domain name
valuations that we saw during the pandemic.
This
year offers the opportunity to ramp up our advocacy
for an update to the outdated Uniform
Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP)
so that domain investors are not subject to so many
spurious complaints and don't have our assets put at
risk of loss due to vague, subjective and obsolete
criteria as to what constitutes a bad faith
registration. Domain investors can help the
cause by being good citizens, staying away from
well-known trademarks, and by voluntarily
transferring any "squatty" registrations
that were inadvertently registered. With
ICANN's review of the UDRP finally commencing likely
later this year or early next year, we have a
once in a generation opportunity to place the
domain investing industry on a firmer footing by
fixing the flaws in the UDRP.
The
Internet
Commerce Association (ICA) has quadrupled
its membership over the past few years and has grown
and strengthened our Board. Our members are a
tremendous resource and we aim to leverage this
network by expanding on last year's first ICA-specific
in-person
meetup with a larger in-person event (if
circumstances allow), offering a Discord
channel for our members where we can share our
knowledge, challenges and successes, and continuing
our series of expert webinars and online events with
leading members of the industry.
Looking
forward to seeing many of you in person this year! |
Braden
Pollock
Founder, LegalBrandMarketing.com
Multi-talented
Los Angeleno Braden Pollock, one of the industry most
widely-known domain investor/developers, is
primarily an Angel Investor who has invested in some two
dozen technology start-ups. He has also purchased more than
a dozen small companies
that have been rolled up into existing companies that he
owns and operates.
Braden
Pollock
Founder
LegalBrandMarketing.com |
The
domain aftermarket continued to provide robust
sales and increased pricing throughout 2021.
I've had more inquiries and sales in 2021 than
any other year in the past, particularly towards
year-end. COVID started this trend mid-2020 and I
don't see the market cooling off any time soon. The DNJournal
2021 Top 100 Sales Chart is the highest
it's been in many years. It now takes 6-figures to
get in the top 100. And let's not forget that most
sales, particularly at the high end, are not public.
The
last few years my focus has been on the high end of
the market and recently I've noticed end-users
increasing their budgets. Thankfully, many
buyers are starting to understand the value of
premium domains. With so many domain investors also
investing in NFTs this past year (myself
included), this has created some buying
opportunities between investors.
This
last year has seen many new blockchain, crypto,
NFT, metaverse and other Web3
companies spring up, using alternative TLD's like .io,
.co, .gg, .so, .fi and
especially .xyz. This demand has, of course,
driven up the price in a few of these extensions.
Several years ago, Google's parent company
rebranded using Alphabet.xyz. Recently Square
rebranded using Block.xyz.
|
This
organic adoption of .xyz by these high profile
companies is a boon for the extension and has
further fueled it's usage.
In
2022 crypto and NFT's will continue to be a
part of the investment strategy for many domain
investors. This will continue to create buying
opportunities for those investors not quite as
interested in that area of the market. That said,
the overall retail domain sales volume will
continue to increase along with sale prices.
Last
year I anticipated fractional ownership
opportunities which have yet to materialize. I
suspect that's still coming. I also anticipated more
marketplaces rolling out payment plans. BrandBucket
did, indeed, launch financing and I suspect GoDaddy
will launch this feature in 2022.
I
predict that alt-TLD's will become better
known by the general public as Web3 companies
continue to adopt them. As such, we may see
start-ups leaning towards alt-TLD's to obtain a
premium SLD as opposed to choosing a long SLD on the
.com. On the other hand, well-funded companies will
increase their domain budget to buy the best
possible domain they can afford. As I've always
said, domains are budget-driven. I don't see that
changing.
I’ve
never been more bullish on the domain market. |
Andrew
Allemann
Founder, Domain
Name Wire
Andrew
Allemann, who founded Domain Name Wire in 2005, is one
my colleagues in the domain media corps and, like all of us
who write about domains, he is also a veteran domain
investor with countless acquisitions and sales to his
credit. He knows this industry inside out and can always be
counted on for an educated and honest opinion on anything
related to domains.
Andrew
Allemann
Founder
DomainNameWire.com |
Much
happened in 2021 but there are some definite themes.
For many domain investors, I think 2021 will be the
year we look back to as the point when non-com
domains started to sell for high prices in the
aftermarket. That's not to say .com isn't
still king, it's just that there's proof you can
make money investing in new TLDs and other
extensions. Exhibit A is Swetha Yenugula, a
successful .xyz investor. Coming into 2021
she was already profitable with .xyz, and then it
simply exploded during 2021. You can
thank emerging trends for some of this. Second level
domains including eth or meta have
sold in many different extensions.
Of
course, 2021 was also a year of incredible
aftermarket domain sales. Comparing the DNJournal
chart for 2021 vs. 2020 is breathtaking.
All types of assets are selling for a lot more than
they used to, but domains are uniquely positioned
to take advantage of both asset price
appreciation and the move to digital during the
pandemic.
When
making short term predictions, most people take
recent history and project it forward. So it's
natural to make predictions about strong domain
aftermarket sales, interest in metaverse, blockchain,
and NFTs. |
I
think we'll be talking about these throughout 2022,
but a bigger question is if some of the froth in
asset markets dissipates. The answer is yes; the
harder question is when. I long ago stopped
predicting things like stock markets and inflation.
But something has to give at some point. I
think domains will be relatively safe when this
happens because they are a useful asset. The first
sign of some of the air being let out might come in
the domainer aftermarket. The prices some people are
paying for expired domains cannot be sustainable in
the long run without a major upshift in resale
values or sell-through rates. A reduction in these
prices would be a good thing and a healthy
sign for the market, not a sign of impending doom. |
Next
up....
Domain
Brokers
Chris
Zuiker
Head of Sales and Marketing, Media
Options
Media
Options, founded by Andrew Rosener, has won
repeatedly been honored as the top selling independent
brokerage in the domain industry. In 2021 they rang up
nearly $100 million in sales. Andrew told me
"That is unparalleled by any other company in the
industry in history on a per employee basis!" A key cog
in the Media Options machine is Head of Marketing &
Sales Chris Zuiker, who we are happy to have
representing MO in this years report.
Chris
Zuiker
COO, MediaOptions.com |
Last
year (2021) was an amazing year for
the understanding of the value of domain names to
branding, marketing and scaling. Media Options
works with all tiers of the business community,
including start-up incubators (self funded, first
few rounds, and fully funded), legacy brands, and
the Fortune 500 companies. The most
significant trend we experienced was the shift in
the global view of domain names from being a
"nice to have" to a "need to
have". This was being driven by the VC/PE
investors looking to protect their investment and
scale their businesses.
This
trend was coupled with the major shift of every
company going either fully online or a larger
part of their revenue moving online. What
this meant is that our acquisition business doubled
from the previous year. Domain names are being
viewed as an asset, not a liability. This is profound
because it raises the floor price for premium domain
names. In my opinion, this is the best thing
to happen to our industry because it is a sustainable
factor for future growth versus previous
bubbles. This paradigm shift brings the sales
prices closer to the true value of domain names. |
Another
smaller trend was the focus of brands and companies
on country-code domains and new gTLDs.
Some good examples were the rebrands of Spiral.xyz
and Block.xyz. While the raw version of
the (.com) will always be king, it does
open up the market for new domain
extensions. This was a small shift but one for
investors to consider for the future.
We
also experienced a rapid escalation in specific
trending verticals. The most obvious were the NFT
and Metaverse trends. As with many
trends, I would advise to make sure to capture this
one while it is hot.
From
a business perspective, 2021 was the best year in
our company’s history. In 2020 we had
the start of the paradigm shift, but 2021 was the
acceleration of the trends and signals we have been
picking up on and pondering for the last decade.
This past year will be seen as the hardening where digital
real estate solidified it’s absorption of the
"brick and mortar" market.
2022
is going to be another great year for domain names.
I see this being heavily weighted in the first two
quarters. There is still a lot of money
looking for a home, but also storm clouds on the
horizon. However, we do not believe that from an
economic, social or even political standpoint we
will see much “relief” from the Covid blanket.
There is still too much uncertainty around
lockdowns, supply chains, and the global economy.
This is why we believe the first half of the year
will be stronger than the back half.
Two
of the sharpest people in the domain brokerage
business, Media Options Founder Andrew Rosener
(left) and Head of Sales and Marketing Chris Zuiker
at NamesCon Global (2019) in Las Vegas.
2021
saw a slew of high tech IPO’s that will
likely continue into early 2022. The biggest winner
there is the venture capital market. Despite what
anyone may say, the biggest driver of the domain name
market, or better domain name prices, is venture
capital. As venture capital goes, so do domain
names. There is a flood of liquidity in the VC market
and more to come. They have a mandate to reinvest that
capital and that means more and bigger funding
rounds for startups. From what I can tell, $1
million is the new $100,000 and $1 Billion
is the new $1 Million. That means more domain name
sales and likely materially higher values as more
demand chases less supply of premium domains.
Lastly,
.COM will accelerate fastest but as prices
increase rapidly, lease options and lease-to-own
models will become the norm as opposed to the
outlier, and large portfolio owners will begin
treating their names more like venture capital than
assets to be sold. At the fringe, those who are not
savvy enough to take advantage of these cashflow-advantaged
lease models for premium .com domains will likely
adopt lesser domain extensions. |
Kate
Buckley
Founder & Principal,
Buckley
Media
Seeing
domain name sales brokered by Kate Buckley
at the top of DNJournal.com charts has become a common occurrence
over the years as Kate continues to ring up sales of six and seven
figure sales with astonishing regularity (her 2021 sale of eBike.com
at $1,089,000 is a recent example). Kate also has a
fascinating life story, one that we detailed in a 2018 DN
Journal Cover Story. Here is Kate's
take on 2021 as well as the new year ahead.
Kate
Buckley
Founder & Principal
Buckley Media |
For
2021, I predicted increased global
adoption of Cryptocurrencies, along
with increased acceptance for non-tangible
assets, including domain names. That
happened in spades. The explosion of the NFT
space may have diverted some funds away
from the wholesale aftermarket as many
domain investors moved to NFTs, however it
had no discernible effect on the retail
aftermarket with sales continuing to
reach new heights due to scarcity of
and demand for consumer-facing premium
.coms.
Legacy
businesses upgraded their digital brand
and well-funded startups sought out the
best virtual real estate possible, so we
saw demand for premium .COM domain
names continuing to drive the premium
domain aftermarket. From private sales to
public, 2021 expanded the momentum of the
2020 premium domain aftermarket. On both
the buy and sale sides, we closed out one
of our most successful years to-date.
For
2022, I envision further global
adoption of and use cases for bluechip cryptocurrencies,
as well as continued investment in NFTs
and the metaverse (with tremendous
VC money flooding the space), driving up
domain prices for relevant sectors.
We’re also seeing huge demand for
premium domains in FinTech, AI,
IoT, MedTech and EdTech.
Voice search is also increasingly
relevant, driving demand for premium
domain names that easily pass the radio
test.
|
Inflation
remains a very real concern which also
increases demand for hard assets
such as domain names, real estate, gold
and BTC as a hedge. The longterm economic
forecast is uncertain and interest rates
are rising, but premium .COM domains have
proven their worth through economic
turbulence before and, particularly given
the need for businesses to operate on the
best virtual real estate possible in this
new normal, I see no reason for them not
to weather any storm on the horizon.
To
that end, it’s worth noting that we’re
receiving domain acquisition (buy side)
requests like never before — a
veritable flood of them in the last week
alone. On the sell side, while I still
spend a lot of time educating end users,
I’ve never before seen both startups and
legacy companies so quickly grasping the
need to operate on the best premium .COM
money can buy…and going for it!
|
Joe
Uddeme
Domain Expert & Principal, NameExperts.com
Joe
Uddeme entered the domain business as the Director of
Business Development at Domain Holdings. After five
successful years there he opened his own shop at NameExperts.com
in 2015 and since then has racked up over $80 million in
sales. In 2021 Joe posted the biggest non .com sale of year,
moving Poker.net for $750,000.
Joe
Uddeme
Domain Expert & Principal
NameExperts.com |
Historically
speaking, domain names has always had two
components. The investor, and the End-user.
In 2021, there was a huge influx of dollars and
investments going into cryptocurrency, and
more so, into NFTs. Many domain investors
began trading in NFTs and digital art. This has
greatly increased the amount of money that has been
re-purposed from domain name investments, to
additional NFTs. This escalated considerably in the
2nd and 3rd quarters of 2021. It continues to be a dominant
factor for domain investors. Domain investors
continued to look for deals and names that would
ultimately, increase in value.
The
End-user is unaffected by the alternative
investments in NFTs. Domain end-users continued
to acquire their brands defensive domain names, or
shortened their existing brand. There has been a
steady increase in the new acquisition requests
for alternatives to .com. The most popular,
cost-effective alternatives have shown considerable
increase in .co, .io, and .ai.
Additionally, brands are continually taking their
long-tail .com and shortening to something
that’s easy to remember and spell. .COM
continued to outpace all other TLDs with the average
price increasing considerably across the board for
all single word, generic .com domains, as well as a
nice uptick for two-word (commerce-driven)
.coms. |
2021
proved to be an incredible year—even with
the challenges of the Pandemic, as well as investors
looking for other avenues to grow their assets. The
explosion of NFTs has limited the amount of investor
money that typically flows into the liquid domain
name market. This proved to be the single largest
impact on the liquidity of domain names—in
general.
There’s
no reason to expect a downturn in investors turning
to alternative investments. NFTS and Crypto will
continue to eat into the investor market.
End-user acquisitions should continue in earnest
with new acquisition starts currently pointing up.
Brands will continue acquiring domains that fill an
immediate need; either from a defensive strategy, or
emerging startups. Both single word, and two-word
.coms will continue to dominate the landscape.
Alternative TLDS such as .io, .co, and .ai will
continue to gain popularity with users looking for a
reasonable, cost-effective alternative to the .com.
Additionally, expect to see a steady increase in .xyz
and alternative extensions related to crypto,
but not currently controlled on the DNS registry
system. .ETH, .Crypto, .NFT and
.Wallet hold relevance with the sales-pitch of
no renewal fees ever.
Now
more than ever, a qualified domain name expert, or
broker should always be used to help navigate
the intricate World of the Aftermarket. 2022
should continue to see growth in acquisitions.
The biggest challenge facing the domain name
industry at-large, is with the Whois system,
and the redacted contact data due to privacy
concerns and GDPR.
Strong
sales should continue with Brands racing to
strengthen their online presence in the wake of the
ongoing Pandemic. We look forward to helping clients
acquire, and divest their premium domain name,
digital real estate. |
Andrew
Miller
Founder & President, ATM
Holdings, Inc.
When
you talk about longevity in the domain world a lot of people
have been around long enough now to be called veterans but
there aren't too many real pioneers - people who who
were successfully plying the trade in the 1990s - over 20
years ago now! Andrew Miller is one of the pioneers
and he has the track record to prove it.
Andrew
Miller
Founder & President
ATM Holdings, Inc. |
I
have been deeply involved in all aspects of
domain name assets since 1997, as a
Founder/CEO, investor, and advisor on many of the
most significant buy and sell side deals, and 2021
was a landmark year in the history of both
domains and emerging digital assets. While many
domain industry experts will make an argument, valid
in many ways, that 2021 was a marquee year for
secondary TLD's, all those other than .com, I
see it as the year that the premium, generic .com
domains reached the next level of acceptance
and value as an asset class. There have been flashes of
this at other times over the years, especially in
the late 1990's, but in 2021, premium .com
acquisitions were closing at the pace of several a
week, and the buyers were end users that were
already market leaders or emerging ones.
It
was almost automatic that a company that
closed a major funding round, a Series A or D, would
inevitably announce the acquisition of their exact
match category .com domain name shortly
thereafter. While other companies decided to
"spend down" to buy an .io or
.xyz, many of the .com deals were companies then
upgrading to .com when they had the capital
and opportunity to do so. I have said this many
times before, and will continue to. The more a
company spends |
marketing
dollars and clout on a non .com, the more traffic,
revenue, and customers they will send to the .com. Best
case it's lost or delayed business, and worst case
it feeds a competitor.
If
you spend one week absorbing media; prime time
television, billboards as you drive on the highway,
print, radio, you will see almost exclusively
.com, to the tune of hundreds of millions of
dollars of advertising further cementing the .com as
part of the brand. Without naming the company I
recently helped a very large, fast growing company
using .io, acquire their .com, and in
the process, discovered over 50 confidential emails
sent by the acquirer's senior management to other
inside management using the .com email even though
it was not their domain. Why? The .com is embedded
in the landscape and mindshare.
For
ATM Holdings, 2021 was highlighted by three
of the largest dollar domain transactions I have
overseen, in all cases movers and shakers that
were leveraging the domain asset to get to their
next level. The most unexpected trend for me is
easy, and is likely shared by many of my domain
peers. I have been studying the coming of
Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT's) for a while, so I am
positioned to be an early adapter and expert in
the same way as I have been with domains. However, I
could not have ever imagined how the Bored Ape
Yacht Club NFT I acquired could have such a
material impact on my business, my already strong
network, my life, and as a stand alone investment,
and I believe it is the "Amazon of NFT's, still
so very early". I covered this in my stories
for Decrypt.
Image
from Bigstock
I
am excited for 2022, but I also envision
there will be some corrections in the public
markets, as well as digital assets. With that said,
and reiterating the theme above, the bluest of blue
chips will hold their value better than 99 percent
of assets in domains and NFT's. Yes, this means premium
.com domains will be strengthened while secondary
domains will stumble, and in some cases cease to
exist, and Bored Ape Yacht Club will flourish, while
a large portion of the NFT projects that came to
market without much substance will be wiped out
in the same way Internet companies were in the
bubble burst of 2000.
We
are entering the most exciting time in technology
since the dawn of ecommerce. We can call it web
3.0, or the Metaverse, but those are fancy names for
a fundamental shift in the way companies and
people transact, engage, and go about their daily
lives. Convergence of the Internet and Television is
finally here, NFTs will replace tickets, clubs, and
memberships, crypto currencies will start to replace
fiat in mainstream applications, and even space
travel and virtual reality is closer (but still a
ways away). New age consumer goods companies
such as Thrasio (full disclosure I am an
investor) will become the "web 3.0 Procter and
Gamble", and technology will develop faster
than it ever has, applied across all categories of
life, including healthcare, entertainment, and
shopping. Premium .com domain names will be the
address and anchor to it all, the address by
which you go from metaverse place A to metaverse
place B, and any talk of that becoming obsolete, as
it has been so many times for so many years, will
continue to be simply noise. |
Ryan
McKegney
CEO, DomainAgents.com
DomainAgents.com
has been making waves ever since the company was founded by
Ryan's brother, Phil McKegney and Adam Strong in 2012. DomainAgents
consistently ranks among the top ten brokerages in the
world, based on total sales volume on the Escrow.com
platform.
Ryan
McKegney
CEO, DomainAgents.com |
In 2021 the
industry as a whole continued to see the impact of
the mass move of business online. At DomainAgents,
we saw the average domain sale price up 25%.
It was easily the best year in our history
and the momentum seems like it will continue into
2022.
Domains are the vanguard of the adoption of
digital assets. While NFTs and the
metaverse still have to prove themselves, domains
have proven value and a 30 year track record of
utility and appreciation. Much of what we see of web3
in 2022 will likely be more foundational than
revolutionary. Hopefully by the end of the
year we will have a better idea of whether domain
based DAOs and alt roots will be viable.
Much like the past two
years, we could see a high degree of volatility
in the world and the economy as a whole. Covid
doesn't seem to be done with us yet and inflation is
on everyone's mind. This instability perhaps makes
domains more attractive though. While other digital
assets may be more 'exciting', domains may prove to
be a safe haven for companies and investors.
Whatever happens, DomainAgents will help buyers and
sellers navigate what comes next. |
Jeff
Gabriel & Amanda Waltz
Co-Founders, SAW.com
Jeff
Gabriel is a world-renowned expert in domain brokerage
and building sales teams and has had a role in over $400
million worth of domain sales. In 2019, Jeff and Amanda
Waltz co-founded Saw.com, a top tier boutique
brokerage that specializes in acquiring, selling, and
appraising domains. Previously, Jeff was the Vice President
of Sales at Uniregistry where he and his team quadrupled
sales dollar volume. Prior to that Jeff was the President
and Co-Founder of Igloo.com and was also a Domain Broker at
Sedo. Amanda is a dedicated, self-motivated business
development professional with over 20 years of internet
sales experience. Amanda is known for her outstanding skills
in business development and communication, as well as her
organizational, conceptualization, and time management
skills. In a reflection of their full partnership, Jeff
& Amanda collaborated on their submission to our State
of the the Industry report.
Jeff
Gabriel and Amanda Waltz
Co-Founders, SAW.com |
After
another year like no other, it would be
difficult to reject the increasing transition many
companies were forced to continue to bring
businesses entirely online due to in-person
restrictions around the pandemic. We believe this is
just one of the key drivers in the sustained growth
of Domain Aftermarket. 2021 exceeded our
expectations and will be remembered as a year we
capitalized on many of the emerging industries
“living” on the blockchain.
The
funding for companies in both Crypto and NFT
space led us to achieve success for many clients who
sought an exact killer match .com domain to
bring their brand to life. Additionally, one of the
higher areas of growth for our team has been helping
upgrade to their exact match .com, which has lead us
to such sales as (to name just a few): Ai.com,
Candy.com, Virtual.com, Alloy.com
and Experience.com.
Today’s
consumers are drawn to authenticity and trust in
branding, especially online. Brands are seeking
the most direct path to engaging with their consumer
and prospective customer base. Companies should make
this easy for their brand loyalists as well as their
prospective customers. We saw this in both 2020 and
2021, and expect this to continue into 2022. Of
course, with the prediction of this pandemic
becoming endemic in April of 2022 we expect people
to reestablish their new normal. We expect
high growth areas for travel, consumer goods, and
also live and interactive experiences.
Companies
in the previously mentioned sectors will need to
continue to drive both traffic and brand awareness
to help fuel their growth and stand out from their
competition.
These
sectors will be poised to experience new brand
creation and will need their online identity to
reflect this. Some will continue to put massive
budgets into creating this identity by purchasing
their exact match.com, as the data shows us with
.com continuing to be the most popular and valuable
with 158 million .com domain names currently
registered. |
Or
if the .com is truly unattainable for them choose
one of the extensions we have seen growing in
popularity and dollar volume such as .ai, .vip,
.law, .io, .co, .tv and
even .gg. In four of those extensions, we
have completed sales that the sale prices were
higher than the highest reported sales.
|
George
Hong
Founder & CEO, Guta.com
George
Hong, a native of China who spent years living in
the U.S and maintains offices in both countries, is
intimately familiar with key buyers and investors on both
sides of the Pacific. When Chinese buyers became a major
force in the domain aftermarket several years ago, George's
brokerage company, Guta.com,
experienced tremendous growth that has catapulted the firm
into the top tier of brokerage services.
George
Hong
Founder & CEO
Guta.com |
In 2021,
end-user domain name sales continued the boom of
2020. According to DN
Journal's 2021 Top 100 Domain Sales
chart, End-users acquired a significant percentage
of domain names.
Eight out of the top ten domain names, such as Hippo.com,
Floor.com,
and Exodus.com,
are actively used by end-users from various
industries, including the crypto industry. 2021 was
a blockbuster year for the crypto space, led by
buzzwords like Metaverse, NFTs, GameFi, Scaling
solutions, and more.
Crypto companies have
spent significant amounts of money buying domain
names and marketing campaigns to promote their
brands. Take Crypto.com, a cryptocurrency
platform, as an example. Crypto.com has been on
a spending spree across the global sports landscape
over the past year. Crypto.com reportedly signed a $700
million deal to rename Staples Center,
the downtown Los Angeles home of the NBA's Lakers
and Clippers, to Crypto.com Arena.
This kind of high-visibility sponsorship deal helps
educate the mass about the value and importance of
domain names.
Many domain investors
have switched or diversified their investments into
the crypto space. Some found that trading NFTs
and cryptocurrencies give them a better
investment return in a shorter timeframe. |
In
2021, Guta helped corporate clients and brand
service companies acquire more domain names than
we did in any prior year. Evolvement and
Innovations in the crypto areas, such as NFT, DAO,
and Web3, will continue to drive the demand for
relevant domain names and provide new
investment opportunities. By following the
trends closely, domain investors can identify new
keywords before they become hot and register or buy
corresponding domain names at relatively low prices.
Experienced
domain investors have an advantage in investing the
new crypto opportunities directly.
Take
NFT investment as an example. Each NFT is unique,
just like domain names. There are many
similarities between investing in domain names and
NFTs. It is not a coincidence that some domain
industry professionals have done pretty well trading
NFTs, especially PFP (Profile Picture) NFTs. |
Tessa
Holcomb
Co-Founder & CEO, DomainAdvisors.com
Tessa
Holcomb was already one of the world’s leading domain
brokers when she launched Domain Advisors in 2010. After
seeing a need for more of a personal approach to domains,
she decided to break away from the large domain sales platforms in order to offer her clients a more boutique
service and provide customized strategies for every client.
Tessa was profiled in a 2015 DNJournal
Cover Story.
Tessa
Holcomb
Co-Founder & CEO
DomainAdvisors.com |
If
the last few years has taught us anything, it’s
not only how important it is to be able to conduct
day to daily activities online, but how
crucial it is to set ourselves apart from our
competition. More companies than ever are
realizing that owning the best domain possible in
your industry not only helps you build instant
credibility but makes it easier for your clients to
find you and, most importantly, for potential
clients to choose you.
As
much of a rollercoaster as 2020 was, 2021 took
things to a new level. While the number of
seven-figure domain sales in 2021 blew away previous
years, the potential for many more was, and still
is, on the table. Budgets are greatly increasing
but nowhere nearly as fast as expectations. As
alternative investments elicit higher returns, and
interest rates remain low, motivation to sell higher
end domain names decreases. Offers are coming in
higher and more frequently than ever for strong
brandables and across very specific, competitive
verticals including finance, healthcare, online
gambling and, of course, the crypto and blockchain
verticals. The competition and lack of motivation
to sell has been pushing up prices and I
only see this continuing.
|
Cash
+ equity plays are on the rise and will continue
to be attractive to both buyers and sellers. Cash
alone doesn’t have the potential to produce the
returns that smart equity trades do and more and
more sellers are prioritizing deals including at
least some equity in a promising business. As
a broker, it’s like a puzzle matching the best
buyer willing to part with valuable equity, to a
domain owner who happens to have a name they want
and sees potential in their business model. Along
those lines, while it had previously been taboo to
introduce the buyer and seller prior to coming to an
agreement on price; it is now becoming more
commonplace, and even constructive, but only when
equity is at play.
What
interest rates do in 2022 will have an impact on the
domain market. Cash has been cheap, making
spending decisions that much easier for both
companies and individuals. As interest rates creep
up, spending will slow, and prices could come down.
Either way, I’m confident about another strong
sales year and hope to celebrate our successes
together, in-person, before year’s end. Here’s
to health, happiness and prosperity in 2022! |
Mark
Ghoriafi
Founder, MrPremium.com
After
learning the domain ropes while working at some of the best
known new gTLD registries in the industry, Mark Ghoriafi,
the founder of MrPremium.com, has emerged
as one of the most successful young brokers in the business
and has made especially big waves selling the increasingly
popular .io TLD.
Mark
Ghoriafi, Founder |
Another
day, another dime, another dollar, another year in
domaining paradise. I am Mark
Ghoriafi, the Founder of MrPremium.com,
a record-breaking domains brokerage, headquartered
in the sun, sand, and sea of South Florida, although
2021 proved to be a sunshine filled year for the
entire domains industry in what may be the most
successful year of publicly reported sales ever!
I
entered into the glorious world of domaining on the
gTLD side of outbound domain sales, working in
Managerial and Director roles at the .CLUB
domains registry, the .GLOBAL registry, and
with Afilias overseeing 20+ domain
extensions. In each role I successfully advanced the
selling of premium domains, achieving millions of
dollars in gTLD sales, and set new industry and
registry records for .Bet .Bio .Black
.Club .Global .Mobi and .Poker.
During
my time at Afilias, I was introduced to .io domains
(Afilias were the backend operator for the .io
extension), and it was as if I locked eyes with a
beautiful lady across the room, knowing the horizons
ahead together would be one of harmonizing
happiness, and sure enough, I was right. |
My
brokerage firm; MrPremium.com, is now a
global-leader for the .io extension with near
$1 Million in .io names sold the past year
(multiple millions in total domain sales), helping
create new paths and contributing to advancing
directions for the .io market. .io has been on a
steady rise the past few years, but the entire
market saw a surge of sales in 2021, substantially
superseding any previous year. To give more clarity,
looking at the reported Top 100 .io domain
sales, we can see:
8 are from 2017
9 are from 2018
9 are from 2019
13 are from 2020
48 are from 2021
(Source: Namebio)
This
means that nearly half of the all-time top 100 .io
sales come from last year alone.
Pre-2021,
seeing a mid-five-figure .io name sale
turned heads and made headlines, which
during that time included the new #1 io sale
of Bank.io for $80,000,
achieved by MrPremium.com in the final weeks
of 2020. Now, let’s fast-forward to one
short year later, and seeing a
mid-five-figure .io sale has become somewhat
unsurprising and fairly standard. In fact,
the industry saw its first ever documented
six-figure .io sale in March 2021 (Metaverse.io
for $175,000), and four more
six-figure sales throughout the year,
including Mint.io for $230,000,
which still claims the top sales spot,
although I am aware of a few .io sales that
have already exceeded this amount in the
private market.
As
a result of this this rapidly advancing .io
market, a challenge that I and the
MrPremium.com brokerage have faced
throughout 2021 is harnessing seller
price expectation of their .io names. Of
the seven-figures of .io domains we have
sold, most have been one-word, singular,
brandable and generic names, but just
because a domain meets these points, does
not mean it’s the next name to sell at
record-breaking price.
We
all can get emotionally attached to the
names we invest in, and many people may even
think they really do have the best names in
the world, but educating yourself with the
external |
Christmas
2021- Mark Ghoriafi is based in South
Florida
but he originally hails from England.
Here he is on his way
back across the Atlantic to see family over
the holidays. |
market,
as well as average selling prices, and the
types of names that are selling at those
prices, is of great importance. Plus, having
an internal think about what you paid for
the name and what your happy ROI would be,
in conjunction with my aforementioned
points, will create a more realistic selling
expectation for today’s market. Just
because a larger notable sale is achieved,
does not mean you now have to price your
names near or above that price point, which
I keep seeing happen in the aftermarket, and
of course this will end up slowing down the
overall sales cycle.
I
believe that with the introduction and
exponential rise of the Metaverse, NFTs,
Cryptocurrency, and in general Tech
startups, combined with the mainstream
acceptance and adoption of the .io extension
within these markets, I only see .io getting
stronger, with horizons of bigger sales in
2022, maybe even seeing the first
seven-figure .io sale by the end of the
year?!
Finally,
it may come as a surprise that I will now
highlight .VC as an extension I feel
has been having some nice under-the-radar
success in 2021, including numerous fruitful
private sales by MrPremium.com. The top five
highest ever reported .VC sales all now
come from 2021, with Defi.vc achieving
top spot ($33,433), followed by Climate.vc
($21,038), Scout.vc ($18,020), Pitch.vc
($15,000) and Product.vc ($10,000).
I do not necessarily think it will be “the
next .io” anytime soon, but I believe it
will provide some notable sales in 2022,
starting to become part of more
conversations, and is worth keeping an eye
out for.
MrPremium.com
is proud to be part of this beautiful
domains community, and is always excited to
be on the frontline of .io and gTLD sales,
(us also representing a selection of
available one-word, category-defining .COMs),
and I look forward to reading fellow
industry friends and colleagues perspectives
about the .COM market in 2021, and their
predictions of 2022 in this State of the
Industry cover story. |
|
*****
Once again, a big
thank you to every domain industry leader who
contributed to this year's State of the Industry
report. Your willingness to share what you have learned from
your years of experience has made ours a stronger industry,
blessed with camaraderie and countless opportunities that are open
to all who wish to pursue them, no matter who you are or
where your are located around the globe.
|